It could've all meant something entirely different.

That's the gist of what could've happened to the finish of The Lord of the Rings: The Render of the Male monarch, Peter Jackson's crowning achievement. Seriously, the movie snagged 11 Academy Awards in every category it was nominated for, including All-time Flick of the Year. More importantly, The Return of the King inspired an unabridged generation to pursue a career in filmmaking and broadly delighted fans of J.R.R. Tolkien'south original work. Oh, and information technology helped the franchise make over a billion dollars...

Peter has been very vocal about what he sees as the fundamental ingredients to adapting Tolkien's masterful work. First and foremost, it'south a determination to stay truthful to the books, fifty-fifty if that ways changing details in favor of an overarching theme or message. For the nigh part, Peter managed to strike every major tone Tolkien had intended in his original trilogy... Although not the Hobbit movies... which is why they sucked.

Simply one chemical element of the ending of the third and final pic in The Lord of the Rings trilogy was and so far from what Tolkien had intended. Had Peter decided to stick with this original ending, he surely would've taken a masterpiece and made information technology... well, decent at best. In short, he could've ruined everything with the unproblematic option of having...

Aragorn Fighting Sauron At The Boxing Of The Black Gate

If you retrieve, Viggo Mortensen'southward Aragorn fights a massive troll during the climactic battle of Return of the Rex. But this was originally supposed to be Sauron... Yes, the flaming center... But in a concrete class.

This choice was not in Tolkien'south '"Return of the King" novel, only it is what managing director Peter Jackson had originally scripted, story-boarded, and even filmed. The raw footage is available online, although most of information technology was digitally changed to make it appear every bit though at that place was a soldier troll there instead.

What nosotros ended up getting was a much improve choice for a multitude of reasons which nosotros'll go into. Notwithstanding, fans are still curious virtually what the fight would have looked like. This has inspired many fans online to accumulate attainable visuals and storyboards in order to brand something that roughly looks like what Peter had originally envisioned.

According to Peter Jackson, the scene was supposed to begin with a wink of calorie-free appearing in front of the army of orcs flooding out of the opening gates. This light would take the shape of Annatar, Sauron'southward true angelic class. According to Tolkien's work, this was the form Sauron took when he managed to fool the elves into making the rings of powers, something we may see in the upcoming television series.

As Aragorn and the fellowship are caught past surprise by the effigy, information technology was to turn into the evil, armored version of Sauron was saw in the prologue to The Fellowship of The Ring. A fight would then ensue and would only end once Frodo destroyed The Ring.

In the making-of documentary from the extended edition of Return of the Rex, Peter Jackson explained that he originally didn't want Sauron to just be a flaming eye on peak of an imposing tower. So, they wanted him to take an appearance in the terminal boxing. Additionally, Peter and his co-writers, Fran Walsh and Phillipa Boyens, felt that Aragorn needed a personal duel with true menace in his life. Of course, this was eventually cut in favor of a fight with a troll.

Why The Fight Was Cut And What That's A Good Affair

There are video essays, including a slap-up one past Pentex Productions, that hash out how the decision to keep this fight could've ruined the pay-off to an otherwise superb trilogy. All of them claim that the creative pick, which had no presence in Tolkien's original work, undermined what the writer was originally trying to do.

Subsequently all, it wasn't a story nigh Aragorn fighting a large bad. In fact, the big bad isn't really even Sauron... It's The Ring.

And the bodily hero of the story isn't Aragorn. It's Frodo, who is also the personification of the theme; "Fifty-fifty the smallest person can alter the course of the future."

"It was non what Tolkien imagined and we realized that it was actually totally demeaning what Aragorn was doing," Peter said in the interview. "The story was so clear as to what was happening. That this was all about Frodo and Sam. And Aragorn realizes that if they're still live then he has to practise what he can to aid Frodo and Sam. And so Aragorn's heroism is not a 1-on-one duel with a big villain. His heroism is his effort to put his ain life and the life of his troops on the line in the vague hope and dream that information technology somehow may give Frodo and Sam that little opportunity to assist them complete their mission."

In society to suit this last-infinitesimal change, Peter pulled together all the footage and had his squad super0impose a troll over Sauron'southward body. Additionally, other components, such every bit the ray of light emitted from Annatar's arrival was manipulated into the eye focusing on Aragorn. This was actually a proposition made by Viggo himself.

Fans are incredibly lucky that the ending of The Return of the King was altered at the last minute every bit it would've betrayed what Tolkien had envisioned and betrayed what the moving picture was ultimately about.

Adjacent: What Peter Jackson Actually Thought About Harvey Weinstein Producing 'Lord Of The Rings'

Ellen Pompeo Says Katherine Heigl Was Right To Criticize 'Grey'southward Anatomy'

Read Next

About The Writer